Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Henderson's avatar

A very pragmatic guide addressing many points that are not evident when heading in this direction. I can see parallele with my own evolving approach but unfortunately think that the clarity you bring won't be realised without experiencing a few knocks along the way. Well said, Alex.

Luke M. Perez's avatar

Interesting piece and quite enjoyed it. I especially like the idea of auto-translated websites. I used to have a github pages but recently replaced with a Carrd landing page. But now I'm re-thinking. Many thanks.

A few follow up questions come to mind about other parts of the piece.

1. You start with a style guide and let it evolve after you make edits. What's a basic one look like? I get why you don't share yours, because then that would color everyone else's. I presume I could start with something like a crib sheet from Chicago, MLA, or whatever, add rules from Strunk & White, and then include any unique things for me (say, "always 'policy-maker' not 'policymaker'" or the other way around depending on each person's style guide). But how long should that first one be, and then how do I decide which edits need to be moved back into the styleguide and which are just one-offs that can be left alone? What else is missing here?

2. I have github and use it sporadically. How does the agent work with github? Is it reading the repo or is it reading the version control from the `.git`files in a folder?

3. Speaking of agents. I'm not sure I follow. Is this the same thing as having the desktop version of the AI or something that each scholar builds for himself?

4. Relatedly, what's your recommendation for scholars who use university issued computers that prohibit agents on their machines? My university laptop is extremely locked down. All software has to be approved through a workday ticket. Many requests are often denied for "security" reasons (read: the university IT dept doesn't want to deal with it at scale). As a result, I have a workflow that relies on my MacBook Neo for all writing and custom software, I use my work issued MacBook Pro for quant work. It's cumbersome but works. I suspect others might only have their work laptop and cannot use an agent or desktop versions.

8 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?