Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Noel Maurer's avatar

Useful study. Interesting literature review. That may not sound like high praise, but it is.

You raise a hypothesis in the introduction, however, that neither your study nor the other ones you cited seems to address: namely that contact with immigrants or direct negative effects from immigrants might reduce support for immigration.

Anecdotes are dangerous, of course, but I lived through the rise in anti-immigrant sentiment in Brooklyn. (Not upscale Brooklyn, to be clear.) My next door neighbor became vociferously anti-immigrant when hotel rates spiked after the refugee influx, forcing him to put up his in-laws in his house when they came to visit. My wife's support for immigration dropped when she began to see little kids selling candy on the subway for the first time, well, ever. The owner of the neighborhood hardware store complained that contractors were hiring utterly unqualified Venezuelans; conversely, my morning coffee conversations at the corner bodega often featured mini-rants about how much cash was being showered upon them making them unwilling to work.

FWIW, everyone involved here is of Puerto Rican or Dominican descent, and the neighborhood swung hard to Trump in 2024. (Not that he got a majority, of course, just a 20-point swing.) In a sense, then, the negative reaction controlled for race and partially-controlled for culture, although I'm still just giving one anecdote.

The question, then, is how much results from surveys reflect how people react when they are directly confronted with effects they find unpleasant or distasteful. The strong effect you find on annual cost per taxpayer, even when presented abstractly and hypothetically, makes me worry that the survey effect won't actually travel to real public opinion.

If my worries give you an idea for future surveys or experiments, then I will consider this comment a success!

P.S. Your findings on linked fate among Latinos don't fit my priors, but I'll admit that I don't have great controls since my personal experience is mostly in New York and Florida. Assuming the result is correct, however, I worry about unobserved variable bias. For example, public education might be more likely to be biased towards immigrants or celebrate ethnic identities. Your finding on Latino-linkage v. immigrants in general leans against that particular hypothesis, but you might want to consider other more direct ways of addressing unobserved variables.

Richard Nerland's avatar

Great article!

It would be very helpful to understand how educational migration can play a more prominent role in integration.

Similarly, it would be helpful to understand if a generous student lending program can fund services to balance costs. Then that allows a higher bar over time. We understand you don't speak Dutch/German/Japanese when you arrive but we will lend you money for classes and we expect you to have language acquisition by year 5. Similarly, we understand you don't have a degree now but we lend you money for certain programs and after 10 years we expect you are over a high bar.

I genuinely don't know how punitive left wing people view lending or how generous right wing people view it. Or similarly how punitive a left wing person views refusing a visa renewal if someone can't learn the language in 5 years.

Sorry that I am asking such a specific question! But I genuinely really appreciate the scholarship and want to learn more.

5 more comments...

Ready for more?