4 Comments
User's avatar
Ebenezer's avatar

There are a number of "soft" approaches here like e-verify, removal of welfare benefits, or deporting immigrants who get arrested for other reasons

Arko Kröger's avatar

My 5 cent to this topic:

Implementation and enforcement of any given policy is inseperatable from the policy itself. If we don't want to hurt humans in the process of trying to control their lifes, then maybe the policy itself is faulty as well. This is also why you cannot just ask what people prefer. It's the migrant itself that chooses his own behavior, not the policy makers. That is, unless you implement control mechanisms with their respective cost, be it monetary or human.

Nicholas Weininger's avatar

What is the state of the research on what citizens even know about their country's immigration policies, both in terms of what the rules are and the enforcement mechanisms used against rule violators?

You often, for example, see people on the left argue as follows:

-- those who oppose unauthorized immigrants often do so because "they should have come the right way" or "they should have waited in line" or "they should have come legally like my grandparents did"

-- but what they don't know is that actually existing immigration rules make it absurdly difficult if not actually impossible for most people to "come the right way", there is no "line" for them to wait in, and at least in the US case, citizens' grandparents who entered pre-1924 did not face such restrictive rules

-- so if we educate people about the reality of these policies, they will be more pro-immigration.

This all seems plausible, but do we know if it's true? And then you can ask analogous questions about whether the cruel and harmful enforcement policies you've listed are things most people even know about. Certainly it seems to me that enforcement authorities have a strong incentive to hide and euphemize the cruelty of what they do; but how much public support would they actually lose if that cruelty were more widely known?

Alexander Kustov's avatar

I have written previously on the public knowledge of the immigration system if you haven’t seen it yet. My guess is that Mollie would say that this may work differently for the question of enforcement than legal admissions: https://www.alexnowrasteh.com/p/spread-the-word-legal-immigration